Philip Rivers and Other Top Names Emerge as Serious Contenders for Buffalo Bills Head Coaching Vacancy

In a surprising twist to the Buffalo Bills’ head coaching search, retired NFL quarterback Philip Rivers has reportedly been placed “under serious consideration” for the role, according to NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport.

The Bills, who parted ways with longtime head coach Sean McDermott following a tumultuous 2025 season, are casting a wide net in their quest for a new leader to guide quarterback Josh Allen and the team back to Super Bowl contention. Rivers, a 17-year veteran who retired after the 2020 season, has spent the last few years coaching at the high school level in Alabama, leading St. Michael Catholic High School to success. His lack of professional coaching experience hasn’t deterred the Bills’ front office, who interviewed him on Friday, with Allen reportedly sitting in on the discussion.

The interest in Rivers stems from his deep football acumen, leadership qualities honed during a Hall of Fame-caliber playing career, and a personal connection to the Bills’ organization. Notably, Rivers shares ties with Bills quarterback coach Davis Webb, and there’s a “shocking Josh Allen connection” that could give him an edge in the search.

Allen, who has been heavily involved in the interview process, views Rivers as a mentor figure capable of unlocking the next level in Buffalo’s offense. ESPN’s Adam Schefter highlighted the interview, noting that Rivers had previously downplayed NFL coaching ambitions but left the door open for the right opportunity.

If hired, Rivers would join a rare group of former players transitioning directly to head coaching without extensive assistant roles, reminiscent of Jim Harbaugh’s path.

However, while Rivers’ candidacy has generated buzz—described as an “unexpected move” by multiple outlets—the Bills are evaluating a robust field of candidates.

The search, led by general manager Brandon Beane, emphasizes offensive innovation to maximize Allen’s talents, but defensive minds are also in the mix. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the other top contenders, based on confirmed interviews and insider reports as of January 25, 2026:

Brian Daboll: The Familiar Favorite

Former Bills offensive coordinator Brian Daboll, who currently serves as head coach of the New York Giants, is reportedly Buffalo’s “top choice” for the position.

Daboll’s tenure in Buffalo from 2018-2021 was instrumental in Allen’s development, transforming him from a raw prospect into an MVP candidate. Despite mixed results with the Giants, including a playoff appearance in 2022, Daboll’s offensive schemes align perfectly with the Bills’ roster. He has already completed at least one interview, and sources indicate mutual interest.

Strengths: Proven track record with Allen; innovative play-calling. Concerns: Recent struggles in New York could raise questions about his head coaching adaptability.

Joe Brady: The Internal Offensive Guru

Bills offensive coordinator Joe Brady, who took over full-time duties in 2024, was the first candidate interviewed on Wednesday.

At 36, Brady brings youth and creativity, having revitalized Buffalo’s offense mid-season in 2023 en route to a strong finish. His LSU background, where he orchestrated Joe Burrow’s Heisman-winning campaign, adds pedigree. However, the Bills reportedly encouraged Brady to explore other options days ago, suggesting he might not be the frontrunner.

Strengths: Familiarity with the current roster; modern passing concepts. Concerns: Limited head coaching experience and potential for internal promotion fatigue.

Mike McDaniel: The Offensive Innovator

Chargers offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel (formerly head coach of the Miami Dolphins) interviewed on Friday, bringing his Shanahan-tree expertise to the table.c18d77 Known for explosive, motion-heavy offenses, McDaniel could pair seamlessly with Allen’s arm strength and mobility. He remains in contention for other jobs, like the Raiders’ head coaching vacancy, but Buffalo’s resources make it an attractive landing spot.

Strengths: Creative scheming; success with mobile QBs. Concerns: Past head coaching stint ended amid reported team issues.

Lou Anarumo: The Defensive Stalwart

Bengals defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo is among the candidates, offering a shift toward a defense-first approach.

His work in Cincinnati, stifling high-powered offenses like the Chiefs and Bills in playoffs, has earned him acclaim. With Buffalo’s defense underperforming in 2025, Anarumo could stabilize that side of the ball while delegating offense to a strong coordinator.

Strengths: Elite defensive mind; playoff pedigree. Concerns: Less emphasis on offense in a QB-driven league.

Anthony Lynn: The Experienced Leader

Commanders run game coordinator and former Chargers head coach Anthony Lynn is set for an interview. Lynn’s prior head coaching experience (2017-2020 with Chargers) includes a 33-31 record and a playoff win. His focus on a balanced attack could complement Allen.

Strengths: Veteran presence; motivational skills. Concerns: Uneven results as a head coach and a step back in recent roles.

Anthony Weaver: The Rising Defensive Coordinator

Former Dolphins defensive coordinator Anthony Weaver, now with the Commanders, brings energy and a modern defensive scheme. At 45, he’s interviewed for multiple HC jobs in recent cycles. His ability to develop young talent aligns with Buffalo’s needs.

Strengths: Player development; aggressive style. Concerns: No head coaching experience yet.

Grant Udinski: The Up-and-Coming Offensive Mind

Jaguars offensive coordinator Grant Udinski rounds out the list with a Sunday interview.a189f0 Known for his work revitalizing Trevor Lawrence, Udinski’s schemes emphasize deep passing and RPO elements.

Strengths: Youthful innovation; QB-friendly systems. Concerns: Relatively unproven at the highest level.

The Bills have conducted at least seven interviews so far, with Allen’s input proving pivotal. Insider reports suggest a decision could come soon, as the team aims to rebuild momentum for the 2026 season.

While Rivers’ potential hire would be a bold, headline-grabbing move, the depth of this candidate pool ensures Buffalo has options to chase that elusive Super Bowl. Fans in Western New York—and across the league—will be watching closely as the next chapter unfolds.