The New York Giants’ decision to draft LSU wide receiver Malik Nabers with the sixth overall pick in the National Football League (NFL) draft has stirred up an argument.

Given their recent struggles at the quarterback position, many observers question why they focused on augmenting their receiving corps instead of recruiting a competent quarterback.

Giants General Manager (GM) Joe Schoen’s confirmation of their draft strategy ignited football analysts and fans alike to thoroughly analyze the rationale behind the controversial move.

Nabers, an exceptional talent and all-time leader in receptions & receiving yards at LSU, is doubtlessly a significant acquisition for the Giants.

The team has struggled to fill the void left by Odell Beckham Jr., who was traded to the Cleveland Browns in 2019. Subsequent efforts to bolster the team’s receiving arsenal with Golden Tate in 2019 and Kenny Golladay in 2021 fell short of expectations and were undoubtedly disappointing.

Thus, Nabers appears to be a beacon of hope for the frustrated Giants fans who long to see an end to these meltdowns. Malik Nabers could be the most talented partner Daniel Jones has ever had in his NFL career.

Embed from Getty Images

However, the question of whether the acquisition of an elite wide receiver is enough to reposition the Giants for success is valid. A cursory glance at any football playbook will reveal that a team’s success hinges as much on the quarterback’s quality as any other player.

Despite Nabers’ undeniable talent and potential, the Giants are stuck with Daniel Jones, Drew Lock, and Tommy DeVito in the quarterback room. Schoen’s affirmation that “I’m comfortable where we are,” reveals a striking denial of the situation at hand.

A crucial point of contention in debates surrounding the Giants’ draft strategy is the fact that Daniel Jones’s performances as a quarterback have been largely underwhelming.

By not prioritizing a quarterback in the draft, the Giants are sending a troubling message; are they settling for less than mediocrity? Yes! With the selection of Malik Nabers, they’ve essentially endorsed Daniel Jones as their primary quarterback, which has generated a significant amount of pushback.

The argument against retaining Jones’s services stems from his less-than-impressive track record. Handing over significant capital to an underperforming player is a dangerous gamble that in my opinion will soon become the Giants’ undoing.

Embed from Getty Images

Some vehemently argue that Jones’s lack of consistency, along with his propensity for turnovers, indicate that he is beyond salvage, Jessie J and I have been saying this for the past 2 years.

Such critics believe that it was a colossal blunder to have wasted precious draft capital on a wide receiver when more pressing needs persist such as finding an effective quarterback.

A a Giants fan, ask yourselves, If Daniel Jones who’s not good, gets hurt do you really trust Drew Lock? No! I think I would trust Tommy DeVito more than any other quarterback on that roster to be honest with you.

While the acquisition of Malik Nabers undoubtedly improves the Giants’ receiving corps, it doesn’t rectify the glaring inadequacies in the team’s quarterback room.

The Giants’ decision to relegate their pressing need for a competent quarterback to the background in favor of selecting a wide receiver raises questions about their vision and their commitment to success. As harsh as it might sound, the Giants’ persistence with Daniel Jones can be equated, in no uncertain terms, to polishing a tarnished object in the hope that it might eventually shine.

Thus, while one can appreciate the brilliance of Malik Nabers, the selective blindness regarding Daniel Jones threatens to cast a cloud over his potential success with the team. Thus, while the Giants’ gamble could pay off in the long run, until then, it appears to be just a risky optimism dressed as a strategy.

Daniel Jones on the Hot Seat!

Embed from Getty Images

But the New York Giants front office will realize it’s not just Daniel Jones who will be on the hot seat next year, he’ll be joined by their head coach Brian Daboll who I’ve never believed to be a good head coach, and their general manager Joseph Schoen.

This has all the makings of a massive s*** show on the grandest stage in the biggest market in the United States.